Ad Hoc 2

More on this subject.

In response to my post here, Gab user LeoJacka9794 who often makes very interesting comments to my Gab posts, provides a list of various HBD ad hoc hypothesis hand-waving, as well as other aspects of HBD pseudoscience. His lists are put together here:

- cold winter theory and their eskimo copes (Their newest one is that eskimos were less group selected and nordics are very group selected Dutton's view).

- Catholicism (as being somehow super eugenic compared to orthodoxy) and hajnal theory.

- protestantism is genetic to northern europeans to cope with the fact that nordic achievements happened after large literacy due to Calvinism.

- historical nordic under-achievement is due to northern europe being so damn cold they couldn't have a leisure class (a 100 IQ with 40 hour free time could invent more then a 120 IQ no free time slave laboring). I remember this in Michael Hart's book. This can easily applied to black under-achievement.

- ancient egypt is over-rated, These are the copes I hear when they accept the fact that ancient egypt was not a "nordic desert empire".

- the islamic caliphate, south east asia and southen european empires are over-rated [also sometimes south asia] to fit with cold winter theory.

- Ireland is over-rated, Ireland is a amazon colony: This is their cope with Irish achievement. Lynn's estimate was to fit with their lower gdp per capita then England, but now Ireland is much richer.

- Chinese under-achievement [like in nobel prizes] is due to the maoism or western / jewish trickery, or chinese historical under-achevement is due to the lack of Maoism smashing the bad traditions.

- "Between 600 and 1300 AD , China was clearly more prosperous than the West", some HBDers like Michael Levin have pushed back against this but it hurts the Asia IQ claim.

- biggish african IQ increases in the recent decades, lynn estimates their genotypic IQ to be 80 and their environment holding them back (Lynn used the worst possible Africa samples, I think his estimates were absurdly low).

- Jews are right wing we just don't let them be right wing.

- the super IQ booster of logographic scripts. conveniently ignoring africans

- East asians have more complex speech sounds [therefore smarter], conveniently ignoring africans. And how languages with complex speech sounds are found most in tropical areas.

- polygenic score will prove everything.

- their is no reason to worry about white replacement after all only high culture matters and east Asians supposedly have a very high culture.

- Devlin says that Lynn and Jensen have "disinterest rationality" (I think this was his review of the autobiography of Lynn's book) due to the previous ad hoc. This is to me is a clear ad hoc, their psychology resembles that of the psychiatric disorder Autism.

- over-rating central asia, sycthans, afghanistan, uyghers (derbs defense of hapas) and other supposedly white groups.

- over-rating Japan and south Korea to fit with cold winter theory and high culture replacement. These countries have serious problems particularly south Korea, there is a ton of illegal Korean immigrants to America and not the other way around.

- over-rating north Korea so you can't use a good international relations for south korea sucess, its just their biology that their successful.

- Ignoring "the klineberg fallacy" (immigrants are not always representative of origin) when it comes to asian immigrants but acknowledging it with africans (I think Jensen who coined it, commited this fallacy). Also using selective high schools like Stuyvesant as objective metrics for smartness and not just immigrant preferences (HBDer edrealist is getting push back for acknowledging this about these high schools)

- Japanese and Korean isolation to cope with Asian under-achievement, that argument can easily apply to Africans.

This all is accurate in its description of HBD mendacity. HBD is a POLITICAL movement designed to privilege Jewish and Asian interests over those of Whites.

Delenda est HBD.